HeartbeatHocusFocusFilesMacHyperTile
Comparison

Ribbon vs Swish

Swish turns trackpad swipes into window commands: snap it, close it, send it to another screen. Ribbon uses the same swipe to slide along a strip that is already arranged.

By Chethan Kumar S N · Updated

Swish and Ribbon are the two Mac window apps that ask you to use the trackpad rather than drag things around. They point the same swipe at two different jobs: Swish fires a command at a window, Ribbon moves the screen along a strip that is already laid out.

The short version

Side by side

SwishRibbon
KindA gesture layer you invoke on a windowA layout that holds by itself
What a swipe doesRuns a command: snap, close, minimise, go full screen, move to the next screenSlides the screen along the strip of windows
Where the gesture livesOn a window’s titlebar by default, everywhere with a Super ModifierAnywhere on the trackpad you have set it up
New windowsOpen where their app puts them, until you snap themArrive as the next column, and nothing shrinks
OverlapFine until you snap, which is the point of the appNone, ever
Grids and exact sizes2×2, 3×2 and 3×3 grids, and dragging a divider resizes several windows at once⌃⌥R cycles ⅓, ½ and ⅔; ⌃⌥F fills and restores; a saved width per app
Moving to another screenSwipe, and multi-display moves follow where the screens physically sit⌃⌥N sends the focused window over, at the width that strip uses
Dock and menu barGestures for those tooNot covered
Closing and minimisingPinch in to close, swipe down to minimise, pinch out for full screen⌘W, ⌘M, the green button
Where you areApp windows on the grid you snapped them intoA strip map that floats up as you move, in six styles
Running it first14-day trialNo trial, 10-day refund, and a demo on the home page
Price$16, one licence on two Macs at a time, or as part of Setapp$15 once, up to 3 Macs
RequiresmacOS 12 or later, Intel and Apple siliconmacOS 14 Sonoma or later, Apple silicon and Intel

Swish is a command. Ribbon is a place.

Swish gives macOS the gesture system it never shipped. Swipe up on a window’s titlebar and it takes the top half. Swipe left and it takes the left third. Keep going and you get a 2 by 2, a 3 by 2 or a 3 by 3 grid, the sort of pixel-clean layout Swish shows off on its own site. Pinch in and the window closes. Swipe down and it minimises. Swipe across and it hops to the display that sits to the left of this one, based on where the screens actually are on your desk rather than which one macOS calls first. Thirty gestures in total, and every one of them is something you do on purpose.

The windows themselves are unchanged. A new window still opens wherever its app decides, which on a large display usually means partly on top of whatever you were reading. You then swipe it into the shape you want, and you swipe again for the next one. Swish’s own comparison with Magnet, Moom and Rectangle says the gestures are quicker and more accurate than dragging to screen edges once you have the muscle memory, and that is easy to believe.

Ribbon moves the arranging earlier. Nothing is placed, because nothing needs to be: each window opens into its own full-height column beside the one you are in, and the strip carries on past the edges of the screen. You navigate with the same kind of swipe, except it is not aimed at a window. It is how you travel. ⌃⌥ ← → does the same from the keyboard, ⌃⌥1–9 jumps straight to a column, and a small map floats up to show where you are on the strip.

Where Swish wins

Where Ribbon wins

What they agree on

Neither app is on the Mac App Store, and for the same reason: Apple’s sandbox does not let an app move windows it does not own. Both ask for Accessibility permission when they start, both need it to stay granted, and both will look broken if it quietly drops. Swish’s own help page sends you to System Settings to re-tick it, which is exactly the advice Ribbon gives.

Can you run both?

You can, and they are less hostile to each other than two snappers are. Swish keeps its gestures inside the titlebar by default so they never fight with scrolling in the window body, and Ribbon is not swiping at windows at all. The workable setup is one owner per gesture: leave Swish in charge of snapping, closing and screen moves, keep it off the windows Ribbon has already arranged, and let Ribbon keep the swipe for travelling. If that still feels crowded, turn Ribbon’s swipe off and move with ⌃⌥ ← →.

One thing to skip: do not snap a window that is on the strip. Both apps would be moving it, and they will take turns correcting each other. Ribbon already leaves dialogs and fixed-size windows alone, and ⌃⌥T floats anything you want out of the strip for good.

Switching from Swish

  1. Open Swish’s settings and switch off the gestures that move or resize windows, or use it alongside Ribbon as above.
  2. Install Ribbon and grant Accessibility access when it asks.
  3. Open your apps in the order you want them and swipe along the strip. If you already have a three-finger swipe set up elsewhere, Ribbon will point out the clash before you hit it.

Or drive the strip in your browser first, with your arrow keys, and see whether the scrolling model suits you before you install anything.

Questions

Is Ribbon a Swish alternative?

Only if what you use Swish for is keeping windows from covering each other. Swish is a gesture layer: you swipe on a window and it snaps, closes, minimises or moves. Ribbon arranges every window on its own full-height column as it opens, so there is nothing to swipe at.

Can I run Swish and Ribbon together?

Yes, if one of them owns the swipe. Swish keeps its gestures inside a window's titlebar so they do not collide with scrolling in the window body, which leaves Ribbon free to read a swipe for moving along the strip. If they still feel tangled, turn Ribbon's swipe off and move with ⌃⌥ ← → instead.

Does Ribbon close and minimise windows with gestures like Swish does?

No. Swish covers that ground well: pinch in to close, swipe down to minimise, pinch out to go full screen. Ribbon only moves windows along the strip, so closing, minimising and full screen stay with what you already use, ⌘W, ⌘M and the green button.

Is Swish free?

No. Swish is $16 from Highly Opinionated, with a 14-day trial, and one licence covers two Macs at a time. It is also on Setapp if you would rather rent it as part of a bundle. Ribbon is $15 once for up to 3 Macs, with a full refund within 10 days and no trial.

Ready? Buy Ribbon for $15, or read all the guides.