# Ribbon vs Loop

> Loop pops a radial menu over the window you are on and you point the way you want it to go. Ribbon arranges every window on a scrolling strip instead. Which one suits your day?

Source: https://www.ribbonmac.com/guides/ribbon-vs-loop · Updated 2026-11-12

**Loop** and **Ribbon** both start from the same complaint, that macOS has never had good window management, and they answer it from opposite ends. Loop gives you a menu you summon over the window you are looking at. Ribbon gives you a layout that is already in place, and you move along it.

## The short version

- **Pick Loop** if you want a command you point at a window. Hold a trigger key, move the cursor in a direction, and the window takes half, a third, a quarter, or the whole screen, or steps to the next display. It is free, open source, and runs on macOS 13 and later.
- **Pick Ribbon** if the part you would rather lose is choosing a shape at all. Every window opens into its own full-height column beside the one you are in, and the strip carries on past the screen's edges. Nothing shrinks and nothing ends up behind anything.

## Side by side

| | Loop | Ribbon |
|---|---|---|
| Kind | A radial menu you summon on the focused window | A layout that is already arranged |
| What you do | Hold the trigger key, point in a direction | Swipe, or press ⌃⌥ ← → |
| Placing windows | You pick a shape for each window, each time | None: a window opens as the next column |
| New windows | Open where their app puts them until you act | Arrive on the strip at full height |
| Overlap | Possible until you move or cycle | None, ever |
| Exact shapes | Halves, quarters, thirds both ways, maximise, almost maximise, centre, macOS centre, full screen | ⌃⌥R cycles ⅓, ½ and ⅔; ⌃⌥F fills and restores; a saved width per app |
| Before you commit | A preview window shows the frame first | Not needed: the window is already where it will stay |
| Stepping through shapes | Cycles: press the same key combination again to go round | ⌃⌥ → walks one column; the strip map shows where you are |
| Windows you want out of the way | Stash hides a window at the screen edge and brings it back on hover or a keybind | Windows are columns rather than clutter, but ⌃⌥T floats one out of the strip and ⌃⌥\` brings it back |
| Scripting | loop:// URLs and AppleScript | ribbon:// URLs, a CLI and Raycast scripts |
| Appearance | Radial menu width, shape and colour; preview padding and border | Six strip map styles, plus a width per app |
| Running it first | Free, so nothing to try | No trial, 10-day refund, and a demo on the home page |
| Price | Free and open source | $15 once, up to 3 Macs |
| Requires | macOS 13 or later | macOS 14 Sonoma or later, Apple silicon and Intel |
| Where it comes from | github.com/MrKai77/Loop, or `brew install loop` | [ribbonmac.com](https://www.ribbonmac.com/) |

## Loop is a menu you point at. Ribbon is a strip that holds.

Loop is built around one gesture. You set a trigger key, hold it, and move the cursor in a direction. A radial menu appears where the cursor is, and the window you were in takes the shape that direction means. Point left for the left half, up and left for the top left quarter, right twice for a right third. Let go of the key and the menu is gone, along with the window's old position.

The part worth copying is the preview: before Loop commits, it draws the frame the window is about to take, so you can see a left two thirds is not what you meant and move the cursor on. There is also a cycle, where pressing the same key combination again steps the window through a series of shapes rather than repeating one, and a stash, which parks a window at the screen edge and brings it back when you hover there or press its keybind.

What Loop does not do is decide anything on its own. A new window still opens where its app puts it, which on a big display usually means partly over whatever you were reading. You then point a direction at it. That is the whole interaction, and it is a good one: it is faster than dragging to a screen edge once the directions are in your fingers, and directions do not need a screen edge to exist, so it works the same on a display with three windows already on it as on an empty one.

Ribbon skips the pointing. The layout is decided as windows open: each one takes its own full-height column beside the one you are in, and the strip runs past the left and right edges of the screen. To reach a window you move the strip, with a three-finger swipe or ⌃⌥ ← →, and ⌃⌥1–9 jumps straight to a column. There are no cells to fill and no menu to open, because at no point is a window waiting for you to decide what shape it should be.

## Where Loop wins

- **Free and open source.** Loop is GPLv3, developed in the open on GitHub, and you can read the whole thing. If a paid app is not on the table, this is the conversation.
- **A shape for every occasion.** Halves, quarters, horizontal thirds, vertical thirds, maximise, almost maximise, centre, macOS centre, full screen, grow and shrink from any edge, move up, down, left and right. Ribbon works in fractions of the screen and a width per app, not in fixed cells.
- **A preview before anything moves.** You see the frame, not the result, which makes a wrong direction a small correction rather than a rearrange.
- **Cycles and stash.** Stepping a window round a set of shapes with one repeated key combination is quick, and hiding a window at the edge is a tidy way to keep something close without it taking a column.
- **Runs on older Macs.** macOS 13 and later, against Ribbon's macOS 14 Sonoma.
- **You keep the keyboard scheme you already have.** Every action is a keybind if you want it, and the radial menu can be turned off entirely.

## Where Ribbon wins

- **Nothing to place, ever.** Open Mail, an editor, a browser and a terminal and you have four columns in the order you opened them, all at full height. No pointing, no cycles, no grid to keep tidy.
- **Nothing hides behind anything.** Pointing at a window is a repair job: the overlap was already there. On the strip there is no overlap to notice in the first place, which matters most on a laptop, where a half-screen window is a small window.
- **The gesture is travel, not a command.** Swiping along the strip follows your fingers the way scrolling does, so it does not take a keybinding to remember, and your modifier keys stay with your apps.
- **Wider screens get better, not busier.** A big display fits as many columns side by side as it has room for and keeps the rest just off screen. [Window management on an ultrawide](https://www.ribbonmac.com/guides/ultrawide-monitor-window-manager-mac) is where this stops being a preference.
- **One purchase, no subscription.** $15 once covers up to 3 Macs, and there is a 10-day refund if it does not fit how you work.

## What they agree on

Both apps are native, both live in your menu bar, and both need Accessibility permission before they can move a window they do not own, because that is the only door macOS opens to any app that manages windows. Turn it off in System Settings and both will look broken in the same way, which is why the first thing to check when a window manager stops working is that switch.

Neither app is on the Mac App Store. Loop is distributed from its GitHub releases and through Homebrew, and Ribbon ships as a signed, notarised download from [ribbonmac.com](https://www.ribbonmac.com/). Same sandbox in both cases: an App Store app cannot move windows belonging to other apps, and moving other apps' windows is the entire job.

## Can you run both?

Yes. They are barely aware of each other, because Loop is idle until you hold its key and never moves anything by itself. The workable setup is to let Loop keep the things Ribbon leaves alone: stash a floating window at the edge, maximise a video call, send something to another display without touching the strip. If you have a habit of snapping with the cursor, Loop still works on floating windows, dialogs and anything you have floated with ⌃⌥T.

The one thing to skip is a Loop action on a window that is already on the strip. Two apps moving the same window is one app undoing the other, and a half-screen window on a strip is both cramped and now outside the layout. Move it with ⌃⌥ → instead, and the strip stays true.

## Switching from Loop

1. Open Loop's settings and pull back to the actions you actually use, or leave the radial menu for floating windows only. There is no rush to uninstall it; a stash at the screen edge is a genuinely good pair with a strip.
2. [Install Ribbon](https://www.ribbonmac.com/) and grant Accessibility access when it asks.
3. Open your apps in the order you want them. If a three-finger swipe is already spoken for, Ribbon will point out the clash before you hit it.

Or [drive the strip in your browser](https://www.ribbonmac.com/#drive) first, with your arrow keys, and see whether a layout that holds by itself is worth giving up the menu.

## FAQ

### Is Ribbon a Loop alternative?

It is, if what you want from Loop is that windows stop covering each other. Loop is a radial menu you summon on a window: hold its trigger key, point in a direction, and that window takes the shape you pointed at. Ribbon arranges every window on its own full-height column as it opens, so there is nothing left to point at.

### Can I run Loop and Ribbon together?

Yes, and it takes less care than two snapping apps do. Loop only acts while you hold its trigger key, so it stays quiet while you move along the strip. The one thing to avoid is a Loop action on a window that is already on the strip: both apps would be moving it and they will take turns correcting each other.

### Does Ribbon have a radial menu or an on-screen grid?

No. Ribbon has no menu to open and no drag targets, because the layout is already there. Widths come from ⌃⌥R, which cycles the focused column through ⅓, ½ and ⅔ of the screen, ⌃⌥F to fill and restore, ⌃⌥C to centre, and each app can remember a width of its own.

### Is Loop free?

Yes. Loop is open source under the GPLv3 and its development is funded through GitHub sponsors. Ribbon is $15 once for up to 3 Macs, with a full refund within 10 days and no trial. If free is the deciding factor, Loop is the free one.
